Best E-mails of the Week 07/11/04.   

What a day on Sunday as I played the role of Aaron Burr's second William VanNess in the Duel reenactment in Weehawken!

Here's my picture in the NYTimes on line today. I have on the brown coat in the lower right hand corner.

Antonio Burr played Aaron Burr, is seen here firing my pistol at Doug Hamilton, playing his great, etc. grandfather Alexander.



Hamilton, Burr Kin Re-enact Famous DuelHamilton, Burr Kin Re-enact Famous Duel
By THE ASSOCIATED PRESS
The bitter grudge between their ancestors has long faded, but on Sunday descendants of Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr marked their paces with pistols in hand.

MORE NEW YORK REGION NEWS
All Headlines
Print Edition Only

 

Hamilton, Burr Kin Re-enact Famous Duel

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Here are some pictures of the duel.

As New Jersey Governor McGreevey finishes his speech, Antonio as Aaron and I are rowed to Weehawken.

The Empire State Building is behind us.

 

 

Antonio is in blue and I am to his right in the back of the 1800's barge powered by four rowers.

 

 

We disembark and I walk toward the stage with directors Bruce left and John right.

 

Into the crowd of 1500, I follow Antonio to the stage.

 

On stage decorated with mountain laurel from Mary and my property.

 

We wait for Hamilton and Pendleton

 

Pendleton is played by Hamilton College Prof. Carl Rubino.   Alexander Hamilton by Doug Hamilton

 

Carl and I role dice to see who stands where. I pace off 10 paces, but those pictures aren't available yet.

 

My big line with my body mike is: "Your choice of pistols Colonel Burr." Recognize my cherry pistol case?

 

The word "Present" is given by Carl, and Antonio lowers my pistol to fire!

 

 

As I wait in the center, under Doug's smoke, he falls back hit.

I was so glad both pistols worked with flints producing enough spark to ignite the black powder in the pan.

Our costume designer Maggie (whose boss won a Tony this year for costume design) said everyone's first question

on being told the Duel would be reenacted was: "Who will be prop master for the pistols?"

Fortunately, Willie deMontreaux of Weehawken was, and everyone was glad he made my pistols work!

Last month, I had chatted with fellow replica dueling pistols owner David Rockefeller that I hoped they would fire well and they did.

Doug falls, (instead of going to one knee) as actor Richard Dreyfus recommended at one of our planning meetings.

 

Antonio rushes forward to console Doug, but I intercept him and lead him away so that the arriving Doctor Hosack

played by Stuart Johnson, our Aaron Burr Association president, cannot testify that he saw Burr at Hamilton's death.

 

Stuart tends to Doug who says "This is a mortal wound doctor" as the reenactment ends.

 

 

Later, my old post college roommate Kevin poses with me.

He and wife Marjorie came over from NYC, and watched with Mary. 

He wouldn't believe I was signing a lot of autographs!!

When someone asked right then when Burr died, Kevin immediately answered 1836! 

Kevin, you da man!! Knowledge of History is power!

Thank you for taking some of these pictures with my camera!

 

In the afternoon, Antonio and Mary leave the plaque dedication ceremony and head for the auditorium.

 

Speakers Tom Fleming who wrote Duel, Joanne Freeman of Yale, and Ron Chernow who wrote Hamilton.

What a job by Lauren, Al, Willie and Ed of the Weehawken Historical Society!

 

 

Here is the AP story on it:

Hamilton, Burr kin re-enact famous, fatal duel

 
 
 
 

By STEVE STRUNSKY
Associated Press Writer

July 11, 2004, 12:43 PM EDT

 

WEEHAWKEN, N.J. -- The bitter grudge between their ancestors has long faded, but descendants of Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr squared off again Sunday with pistols in hand.

Douglas Hamilton, a fifth-great-grandson of Hamilton, and Antonio Burr, a descendant of Burr's cousin, re-enacted the July 11, 1804 duel that left Hamilton mortally wounded and a sitting vice president's reputation sullied.

advertisement
 
       
   
 

The event was the families' first meeting in two centuries.

"It wasn't something on my top 100 list, but it was nice to meet Antonio Burr," Douglas Hamilton said afterward. "He seems to be a very nice man, though I'm not sure I'm going to be on his Christmas card list."

Still Douglas Hamilton noted his famous ancestor had forgiven Aaron Burr on his deathbed and so could he.

"Just being shot 31 hours earlier, if he could forgive Burr, far be it for me not to honor that," said Hamilton, an IBM salesman from suburban Columbus, Ohio.

More than 1,000 people attended the re-enactment near the Hudson River. The original duel's exact site is unknown because the waterfront area is so dramatically different than it was 200 years ago, historians said Sunday.

An estimated 60 descendants of Hamilton attended the event, as did 40 members of the Aaron Burr Association.

Hamilton, a signer of the Constitution and the nation's first treasury secretary, had a simmering feud with his longtime rival Burr, the vice president under Thomas Jefferson.

When Burr ran for governor of New York in early 1804, Hamilton denounced him as untrustworthy. Burr lost. Burr later complained about a newspaper article that reported Hamilton had expressed a "despicable opinion" of him.

Dissatisfied with Hamilton's explanation, Burr challenged him to the duel.

Shot by Burr, Hamilton returned to New York, where he died the next day. Burr was indicted on murder charges in New York and New Jersey but was never tried, and finished his term as vice president in 1805.

Even today, some relatives question how the feud between the two began in the first place.

"There was an animosity on the part of Alexander Hamilton toward Aaron Burr for which there was nothing in Aaron Burr's record that could be justified," Antonio Burr, a psychologist from New York, said Sunday.

At the highly orchestrated event presided over by Weehawken Mayor Richard Turner, Douglas Hamilton and Antonio Burr donned period costumes. They arrived at the riverbank by rowboat with their entourages as their ancestors had 200 years ago.

Then they paced off, firing replicas of the .54-caliber pistols. In feigning the historic hip wound, Douglas Hamilton dropped to one knee and then fell to the ground in a sitting position.

Afterward the participants and their families headed to Hamilton Park where two new plaques honoring Burr and Hamilton were to be dedicated.

 

 

The NY Post has a great color picture of me, but don't believe their story. Remember they were founded by Alexander Hamilton

  They say Hamilton served under Washington and Burr under Arnold, but neglect to say Burr disowned Arnold and was

the real Revolutionary War hero.  For true info, see my web site www.AaronBurrAssociation.org

 

Also in Monday's Washington Post there is a quote by Hamilton author Richard Brookhiser, who did not participate in the reenactment, but spoke today at Trinity Church and Fraunces Tavern. He is in charge of the Hamilton Exhibit this September where they will drape the NYHistorical Society with a giant ten dollar bill. He claimed to my friend that he was misquoted. The Washington Post said:

Other partisans have offered hot words on behalf of the treasury secretary. Brookhiser, particularly, is dismissive of Burr descendants' efforts to achieve historical parity for their man. "You know, it's tough when your relatives have no principles and no accomplishments," Brookhiser said.

We'll see if this gets corrected tomorrow since everything has been positive so far.

 

 

 

 

This was my 15 minutes of fame that Andy Warhol said I could have.

I had a blast doing it. 

Thanks to my friends who were there at the reenactment, and to

all of you who saw it on AOL, Fox News, Cspan or on the network news programs.

 

 

 

Pete   

 


 

 

 

 

Back to the Best E-mails Home Page